auto insurance Wellsville, NY

500 Wayne St., Olean, NY 14760 | Call Us 716-373-5500




At All American Financial Service & Insurance, we help customers throughout Olean, Wellsville, NY and the surrounding areas find the best insurance plans to meet their needs and budget. We know insurance rates can be high, and understanding all the fine print and small details can be complicated. That’s what we’re here for! 

Steven I. Pancio and Michele A. Pancio can help break down your insurance plan in simpler terms, making sure you fully understand what you are getting. After all, home insurance and auto insurance help to cover some of your largest investments in life. Make the right choice and insure some of your most expensive investments with our help. 


At All American Financial Service & Insurance, we specialize in finding homeowners the best home insurance plan that covers nearly anything that could happen, from fires and natural disasters to theft. Although you might not be able to spare your home physically, you can take the proper steps to prevent for any unnecessary financial hardship or damage following the event. 

Keep your beloved home protected now and in the future. Call us today to learn about our homeowners insurance plans. 


Put simply, if you own a car or motorcycle, you need auto or motorcycle insurance. When that time comes, make sure you choose the agents of All American to help with the process. We can help you find the insurance policy that best meets your needs, especially if you drive often for work or personal reasons.

From roadside assistance to collision repairs, medical expenses, bodily injury, property damage, and more, make sure you’re covered from the unforeseen. Call us today for motorcycle insurance!

Premier Insurance Options for Wellsville, Olean & Surrounding Areas

All American Financial Service & Insurance was created in 1991 and has been family-owned and operated ever since. We are an independent insurance agency that has been dedicated to helping clients throughout the Olean and Wellsville areas since we first opened our doors, and are proud to serve our local community every day. 

If you need home insurance, auto insurance, motorcycle insurance, or have any policy-related questions, don’t hesitate to give us a call! Our dedicated team would be happy to answer any questions you might have, or help you find a plan that best fits your needs.

Share by: